Toy & Game Auctions in New Jersey
Overstock, open-box, and customer-return lots at our Paterson, NJ warehouse — 100% online bidding, starting at $5.
Ask any parent who bids with us: toys are the category that pays for the habit. Overstock action figures, LEGO sets, dolls, board games, STEM kits, outdoor play sets, and ride-ons come through weekly — and around the holidays, toy lots take over entire catalogs.
Retail toy prices are built to test a parent’s love. Auction prices aren’t. Winning a $60 building set for $11 two weeks before a birthday party is the kind of thing that turns a first-time bidder into a regular.
Expect names like LEGO, Barbie, Hot Wheels, Fisher-Price, Melissa & Doug, Nerf, and Little Tikes across the year, with big seasonal waves before the holidays.
Bidding Tip: Shop Holidays Early
Toy inventory surges in the weeks before the holiday season and sells hardest the closer it gets. Bid your gift list in October and November while the crowds are still thinking about Halloween candy.
Toys & Games Auction Questions
Are auction toys new?
Most toy lots are brand-new overstock or shelf pulls, sometimes with worn packaging. Condition is photographed and described on every lot — what you see is what you bid on.
When is the best time to bid on toys?
Year-round for everyday deals, but inventory peaks in the run-up to the holidays. Early birds who bid in fall face the least competition per lot.
More questions? See the full auction FAQ or contact us.
A Taste of the Category
A few examples from recent NJX catalogs. Inventory rotates every week, so think of these as a sample of what toys & games auctions can include — not this week’s list.
More Categories to Explore
One catalog, dozens of categories — see what else closes this week.
Local Pickup Across North Jersey
Pick up free at 831 River St, Paterson, NJ — an easy drive from these towns — or have your wins shipped to your door: